Edwards wins by an inch Edwards and Cheney both did a great job.

Cheney came off as tough and smart but cool and not angry. I have rarely heard anyone so masterfully insult another person without sounding angrier. It almost makes me sad that he is an evil cyborg sent to earth to enslave humanity.
Edwards did well as I expected, particualrly in the begining regarding Iraq.

Cheney and Edwards are smart people, unfortunatley ole Dick is a little lacking in the good citizen/ nice guy department.

Heres my chart:

................Brains.....Toughness.....Charisma.....Goodness.....Total
Bush.................1...............3...............9...............2...............15
Cheney............9...............9...............5...............1...............24
Kerry...............9...............7...............8...............8...............32
Edwards..........8...............6...............9...............9...............32
  ¶ 10:13 PM